As soon as I discovered I was having boys, my mind began racing with potential names. The name for my first son felt like a no-brainer: Matthew, after my cherished grandfather who had passed away not long before. But choosing his middle name was a different story. I considered my paternal grandfather’s name, but my husband was keen on honoring his own grandfather, with whom he had a close relationship.
In a moment of innocence, we decided to share our name ideas with family. To my surprise, everyone had strong feelings about the middle name—some even became emotional. While I understood that names can evoke deep connections to loved ones who have passed, I was unprepared for the pressure that would ensue from certain family members about what name we should choose.
Ultimately, we settled on my husband’s grandfather’s name for the middle name. It was a choice we liked, but I couldn’t shake the feeling that it was also influenced by the overwhelming pressure and guilt we felt from our relatives.
This experience was just the beginning of my family’s strong opinions about parenting choices, from sleep habits to feeding methods. Over time, I developed a thicker skin and felt more confident in my decisions as a mother. However, when it came time to name our second child, I made the same mistake of involving family in the conversation.
Why hadn’t I learned from the first experience? This time, we weren’t considering any names tied to deceased relatives. Instead, we aimed for something simple yet meaningful. Names like Lucas, Leo, and Henry were on our shortlist. We were particularly drawn to Henry, inspired by bedtime stories featuring brave knights.
When we casually mentioned “Henry” to family, reactions varied widely. While some were supportive, others were downright opposed, even saying, “Please don’t choose that name.” I didn’t even want to dig into their reasons. I was taken aback; it was uncomfortable, and I found myself escaping to the bathroom to cry.
Looking back, it may seem overly dramatic, but I knew in my heart that our son was meant to be a Henry. The reactions were tough to swallow, especially with my heightened emotions. That same evening, my water broke, and I went into labor.
Although the name debate didn’t overshadow the actual labor experience, it lingered in the back of my mind. When my baby finally arrived, with his tiny features and curious gaze, we affectionately referred to him as “Little Knight.” An hour later, our older son came to meet him and immediately asked what we had decided on for his name. When we said we hadn’t settled on one yet, he looked at us with disbelief and exclaimed, “His name is Henry!”
That moment solidified our choice. As for our family members who had initially disapproved, they remained quiet once Henry arrived. There was no longer room for discussion or debate.
I don’t entirely blame my family for their unsolicited opinions regarding our name choices. They could have been more open-minded, but we did open the door for their feedback. In the end, naming your child should be a personal decision made by you and your partner, free from outside influence. Truly, no one else’s opinion should matter. After all, we’re not talking about naming our children anything outrageous or harmful—just a name.
If I could go back in time, I would keep my naming choices entirely to myself. No sharing, no asking for opinions—just our little secret until the big reveal.
For more insights on family dynamics and pregnancy, check out one of our other blog posts here. If you’re considering at-home insemination, reputable retailers like Cryobaby offer kits that can help. Additionally, the NHS provides excellent resources about pregnancy and home insemination.
Summary
Sharing baby name ideas with family can lead to unexpected pressure and strong opinions. Personal choices, especially when it comes to naming children, should ultimately remain private between parents. It’s essential to trust your instincts and make the decision that feels right for you, without outside influence.
Leave a Reply