“Mommy, are you going to have a baby?”
“Mommy, why are there two seats in this cart?”
“If I had a baby brother, I’d be the best big sister!”
“Mommy, look, I’m pretending to be pregnant!”
“Why does she have a baby sister and I don’t?”
“Mommy, when I go to sleep, you and Daddy can make a baby!”
“Daddy, did you plant your seed in Mommy’s belly, and then she grew me?”
“When I’m a grown-up, I’m going to have a million kids!”
These sweet yet persistent inquiries from my 3-year-old, Lucy, about welcoming a sibling have become a regular part of my day. If it’s not her asking, it’s my husband, Mark, with his hopeful gaze, reminding me of the joy a new baby would bring to our family. On top of that, there’s societal pressure that makes opting for just one child feel like a grave misstep. My anxiety about disappointing Lucy, Mark, and even distant relatives looms large, compounded by my fear of being judged as a “failed woman” for not fulfilling the traditional role of the all-capable mother.
All of this presumes, of course, that I can get pregnant. After more than 18 months of trying, with inconclusive medical tests and no clear answers, that remains uncertain.
Just a year ago, my longing for a second child was intense. I frequently found myself at Target purchasing ovulation kits and pregnancy tests, feeling a tug in my heart whenever I saw expectant mothers. I envisioned our family expanding, often daydreaming about the joy a new member would bring. Each month, as I experienced the typical signs of pregnancy, my hope would swell. But as months turned into a frustrating cycle of disappointment, my enthusiasm waned. We began to track fertility signs meticulously, consulted fertility specialists, and even dove into acupuncture and dietary changes, all while enduring tests with no definitive answers. My hope slowly morphed into frustration, and eventually, into indifference.
Now, my perspective has shifted dramatically. I find myself relieved each time my period arrives, and I’ve taken to using condoms with a new sense of purpose. Mark and I have even started couples counseling to navigate our differing views on family planning. He yearns for another child, aiming to replicate the joy we felt with Lucy, while I can’t shake the feeling that adding another child would be exhausting.
I remember all too well the fatigue of the first trimester, the physical changes, the challenges of labor, and the relentless cycle of sleep deprivation. Mark believes I’m being shortsighted, arguing that the hardships are temporary and that we could ultimately create a loving family of four. But grappling with my feelings and explaining them to him feels like an uphill battle.
My first pregnancy was smooth, and the experience of becoming a mother brought me immense joy, but I don’t feel that same urge for another child. I’m genuinely content with our family of three. Life has shifted; Lucy is now at an age where we can enjoy adventures together—hiking, biking, and camping—without being tethered to the demands of an infant. I’ve rediscovered my independence and feel good about it.
Some friends gently wonder if my change of heart is a reaction to our fertility challenges. I can’t say for sure, but the thought of navigating pregnancy and infant care again feels daunting. I often feel isolated in my indecision. Many friends have already expanded their families, and their mantra seems to be, “It’s hard, but we manage!”
I find myself torn between three distinct groups: the “One and Done” crowd, those actively “Trying to Conceive” (TTC), and the “Dual Income No Kids” (DINK) lifestyle. While I relate to all these groups in some way, I don’t fully fit into any of them. Perhaps I should start a support group called “Infertile and Indifferent.” Members would share a positive experience with their first pregnancies and the joys of motherhood, yet feel ambivalent about expanding their families further.
I pride myself on being open to various family structures, yet I find myself questioning my own feelings. If I was once sure I wanted more children, why do I feel differently now? Mark seems to think this is just a phase, waiting for my feelings to swing back toward wanting another baby.
The decision to grow our family—or not—feels fraught with significant emotional weight. It’s a binary choice: to try for another child or to decide against it. And time is not on our side. The potential for regret lingers, regardless of the path we choose.
If you’re navigating similar feelings, you’re not alone. Many women deal with complex emotions about family expansion, especially when faced with fertility issues. You can find more insights in our other blog post here. Additionally, if you’re considering at-home insemination, check out this reputable retailer for syringe kits that can help you on your journey. For more information on fertility treatments, this resource is excellent for those exploring their options.
In summary, my journey through infertility and indecision about having another child has been anything but straightforward. I’ve come to appreciate the family I already have while grappling with societal and personal pressures. It’s a challenging balance, but one that many parents face in today’s world.
Leave a Reply