During a summer math examination in the U.K., students were taken aback by a peculiar question that required them to compute the total calories in a woman’s breakfast. The inquiry raised numerous concerns, so let’s break it down.
The Math Problem
The math problem stated: “There are 84 calories in 100g of banana. There are 87 calories in 100g of yogurt. Priti has 60g of banana and 150g of yogurt for breakfast. Work out the total number of calories in this breakfast.” This question was part of the GCSE exam, a mandatory test for all 16-year-olds in the country.
Concerns Raised
One of the primary issues with this question is its potential to trigger students who may struggle with eating disorders. Such calculations can be harmful, especially for those who have experienced or are currently dealing with these issues. It’s vital to consider that anorexia is among the most prevalent chronic conditions affecting adolescents, and 95% of individuals with eating disorders are aged between 12 and 25. Consequently, at 16, students are especially vulnerable, and exposure to this question could evoke distressing memories for some.
A student interviewed by a local news outlet expressed how the question caused her significant anxiety. “Reading it brought back a flood of memories about calorie counting, and I panicked, so I had to step out for a bit until a teaching assistant helped me calm down,” she shared.
Analyzing the Math
This alone could warrant the removal of the question; however, let’s examine the math involved. The total comes to 180.9 calories — 50.4 from the banana and 130.5 from the yogurt. Notably, this is presented as a woman’s breakfast. In reality, consuming fewer than 200 calories for breakfast is insufficient and wouldn’t provide the necessary energy for a productive day. Promoting such a low caloric intake as acceptable for a growing young woman is concerning, especially when teenagers need adequate nutrition during this critical phase of growth.
School Officials’ Response
Despite the backlash and calls for reconsideration, school officials deemed the question “valid.” They overlooked the fact that there are countless other ways for students to demonstrate their understanding of mathematical concepts.
We empathize with the students affected by this question and hope that the discussions happening online prompt school authorities to reassess their decision and create a more supportive learning environment. For more insights on related subjects, check out this blog post on our site about navigating these challenges.
Conclusion
In summary, a math exam question involving calorie counting for a woman’s breakfast has sparked significant concern among students and parents, highlighting the potential harm such inquiries can cause to individuals with eating disorders. School officials have defended the question, despite its troubling implications.