Opening that first can of formula for my daughter felt like a punch to the gut. Sure, sleep deprivation and a whirlwind of postpartum hormones were playing their parts, but it was heartache that topped the list. I had envisioned an exclusive breastfeeding journey. However, after weeks of trying everything from specialist consultations to supplements and perfecting latches, reality hit hard: my milk supply was low. I was up every hour, nursing or pumping, chugging water like it was going out of style. I’ll spare you the gory details about my sore nipples, but let’s just say they’ve seen better days.
Despite our best efforts, my daughter was still left hungry. My body just couldn’t keep up with her demands. Eventually, I made the tough choice to supplement with formula. This only created more supply issues, and by three months, we had transitioned her to formula completely.
When our second child came along, I was determined to succeed this time. Yet, the same supply challenges emerged, compounded by a toddler who demanded my attention every time I settled down to feed the baby. Before long, we were supplementing again, and our second little one was on formula exclusively by the two-month mark.
I felt like I had failed both myself and my children—not once, but twice. The “what ifs” haunted me: What if I had done this differently? What if I had tried harder? I was burdened with guilt—the guilt of not fulfilling what felt like my most fundamental role as a mother: nourishing my child.
I also grappled with the guilt that came when I finally stopped nursing. No more watching the clock; my husband could now give the baby a bottle. I could sip on a margarita without a care. My body was mine again, and I loved it, yet guilt lingered, as if my newfound freedom had come at my children’s expense.
And then there was the omnipresent mantra of “Breast is Best.” I’ve read countless studies touting the advantages of breastfeeding—how it supposedly leads to smarter, healthier kids. Honestly, are these studies even necessary? Who out there is arguing that formula is better? Perhaps we should allocate those research funds toward curing cancer instead.
These factors made me hyper-aware of my breastfeeding journey. I imagined the judgment from other moms as I pulled out a bottle of formula, and the well-meaning comments about breastfeeding benefits felt like daggers. I often found myself needing to defend my choice to formula-feed.
One time, my son’s pediatrician casually mentioned that our baby “missed out on the natural immunities in breastmilk,” and inside, I wanted to yell, “Not YOU too! I did EVERYTHING I could!” But reminders of breastfeeding’s benefits are everywhere—support groups, public service announcements, and entire months dedicated to the cause. While they’re important, they constantly remind me of the breastfeeding bond I never got to experience—the one I yearned for and ultimately grieved.
I longed for a support group of formula-feeding moms who understood my struggles. It would have been fantastic to have our own space to ask questions like: “What’s the trick to getting that last spoonful out of that miserable can?” or “I know I should toss it after 60 minutes, but it’s been 70—how dangerous is that really?” or “Why is something essential for my baby’s survival so incredibly expensive?”
I’m not here to undermine breastfeeding moms. They deserve all the applause and support for their hard work. I’m simply saying that many mothers choose formula for a variety of reasons, and none of them do so out of convenience or vanity.
I’m finally beginning to appreciate my own journey. I’m proud that my body brought two beautiful children into the world and did its best to nourish them, even if it wasn’t how I envisioned. I’ve learned that life is too short to feel guilty about things we cannot change. All we can do is keep trying, keep learning, and recognize the many things we get right along the way.
If you’re looking for more information on pregnancy and home insemination, check out this excellent resource. And if you’re interested in fertility boosters, this is a great place to start.
Summary:
This reflection on the author’s journey with breastfeeding reveals the emotional struggle many mothers face regarding feeding their children. Despite the guilt and societal pressures surrounding breastfeeding, the author learns to embrace her choice to formula-feed, recognizing the love and care she provides her children regardless of how they are fed.