Are participation trophies detrimental to children? This question seems to ignite surprisingly intense debates. It’s interesting to observe that this issue tends to provoke more passion from those without kids than from the parents I know, who often seem indifferent to it.
Having coached young children aged 6 to 7, I may adjust my perspective as my own kids grow older, but I currently see no valid reasoning behind the arguments against participation trophies. The two main points of contention usually fall into the following categories: 1) they diminish the value of sports, and 2) they foster a generation of overly sensitive individuals, particularly among boys.
To those who argue that these trophies devalue sports, I pose a simple question: What motivates kids to attend weekly practices and games for three months if not the love of the sport? Are there truly children out there who say, “Mom, Dad, I have zero interest in baseball, and I couldn’t care less about learning teamwork or making friends, but I’ll keep showing up for practices because I want a trophy”? The notion that participation trophies mislead children about the true merits of sports is nothing more than a straw man argument.
As for the fear that participation trophies will create a generation of softies, I understand the concern. Discussions about masculinity in crisis have been around since at least the early 20th century, and they often seem exaggerated. So let’s save the rhetoric, shall we?
In a few years, I might feel that my oldest child is too mature for participation trophies. However, I suspect that by then, she won’t be particularly interested in receiving one anyway—she hardly even cares about the one she received last season! For now, I remain committed to recognizing the efforts of all the kids I coach by rewarding their attendance, skill development, and teamwork with a participation trophy.
If you’re interested in learning more about related topics, check out this insightful post on our blog here. Additionally, if you’re considering at-home insemination, you can find a reputable supplier of at-home insemination syringe kits here. For a deeper understanding of the process, visit this excellent resource on what to expect during your first IUI here.
In summary, participation trophies serve as a valuable recognition of effort and engagement. They encourage children to participate, learn, and grow, reinforcing positive behaviors rather than undermining them.
Leave a Reply