My fondest memories of school revolve around the library. It was a serene, spacious haven filled not only with textbooks but also with countless novels to enjoy. I thrived during reading assignments and essay writing when I could settle into a study carrel, crafting my notes and drafts at my own pace, free from interruptions. However, group projects were a challenge. Sitting at large tables with my peers often meant more energy was spent managing social dynamics and negotiating workloads than actually engaging with the material. I found myself drained and overwhelmed, often leaving the meetings with homework still unfinished.
According to Michael Godsey in The Atlantic, schools are increasingly emphasizing collaboration, discussions, and “interactive” learning, which tends to overshadow the needs of introverts. This shift away from solitary, quiet learning environments means that introverted students may be losing the very conditions that help them thrive: time and space to read and research independently. Godsey points out, “The rise of educational trends—buzzwords like ‘collaborative learning’ and ‘project-based learning’—often overlook the unique needs of introverts. The current focus on extroverted behavior in classrooms can significantly hinder the learning experiences of students who are more inward-focused and easily fatigued by constant social interactions.”
For introverts, the pressure of mandatory group collaboration can be particularly taxing. Godsey highlights the experiences of two students who transitioned to an “alternative” high school designed for those who struggled in traditional settings. They found success not necessarily through improved social skills, but simply because the new environment was quieter and less hectic.
During my time as a tutor for high schoolers, I frequently encountered students struggling to maintain focus amid a barrage of distractions, even in their own homes. With family members coming and going, phones ringing, and pets barking, it was often overwhelming. When I suggested turning off devices, putting pets outside, and creating a more tranquil space, my students typically showed marked improvement in their ability to concentrate.
Public schools, particularly larger ones, can be far from peaceful or conducive to introspection. The push for collaborative work can create an environment that is challenging for introverts. This raises an interesting question in light of the narrative that “schools are failing boys”—the notion that quieter, more reserved students (often girls) are faring better academically than their more active male counterparts. I can’t help but wonder if the shift toward group learning is an attempt to cater to these more active learners, moving away from a model where students work independently at their desks, which worked wonderfully for me.
Godsey acknowledges that group activities can indeed benefit introverts: “[G]roup activities can play a valuable role in teaching introverted students. With the implementation of Common Core standards and the Internet serving as a substitute for classroom instruction, ‘cooperative learning’ has gained traction among educators in recent years. As English teacher Sarah Jennings observed in The Atlantic, ‘Common Core standards prioritize small-group discussions and student-led activities over traditional, teacher-led instruction.’ Overall, this is a positive trend, as research indicates that students engaged in cooperative learning often outperform those in more conventional lecture-based settings. However, effective cooperative learning doesn’t have to be overly social or stimulating; it can incorporate quieter elements that encourage personal reflection.”
I hope that educational institutions can find a way to cater to both introverted and extroverted students. By the time my children are in school, I wish for them to have ample opportunities to delve into books in the library. Just as extroverts need social interactions, introverts require space to learn in their own manner. They should be able to immerse themselves in reading at a carrel and, when they feel sociable, join their peers at the larger tables.
In conclusion, schools must strive to balance the learning environment to support the diverse needs of all students. Introverts deserve the same opportunities to thrive as their extroverted classmates. For more insights on how to support introverted learners, check out this blog post. Additionally, if you’re exploring fertility options, reputable online retailers like Make a Mom offer at-home insemination kits while NICHD provides excellent resources on pregnancy and home insemination.
Leave a Reply