A recent study has revealed that postponing kindergarten until children reach the age of seven can lead to significant advantages. The research indicates that this delay enhances students’ ability to self-regulate their attention and hyperactivity levels when they eventually enter school. The report, titled “The Gift of Time? School Starting Age and Mental Health,” found that a one-year postponement in starting school can drastically reduce inattention and hyperactivity issues by up to 73% for an average child by age 11. The study analyzed data from tens of thousands of students across Denmark, capturing insights from both boys and girls.
The concept of “redshirting,” or holding children back from starting school at the typical age, has sparked ongoing discussions. Experts in early childhood education have voiced concerns about the pressure on young children to engage in academic work, suggesting that play-based learning is far more beneficial. As one expert pointed out, “It’s not just about when to start kindergarten, but rather what’s happening in those kindergarten classrooms. If kindergarten is treated like first grade, parents may understandably choose to delay their child’s entry.”
There are conflicting studies regarding the merits of delaying a child’s start in school. Personally, I hadn’t formed a strong opinion on the matter until my son began kindergarten this year at just four years old. After relocating from Florida to New York, my son missed pre-K altogether. With New York’s cutoff date for kindergarten admission being three months later than Florida’s, he was suddenly considered ready. Although I worried he might be too young, I followed the state’s guidelines and enrolled him.
The transition has been challenging for him, moving from a part-time daycare to a full-time classroom environment with only one brief recess. I recently received a call from the school psychologist, informing me that he was exhibiting attention issues. “He reads exceptionally well, but his comprehension is lacking,” they said. “Have you noticed he refers to himself in the third person?” My immediate thought was, “He’s not even five! He’s used to napping. Is this really a necessary call from the school psychologist?”
My son has been reading since he was three and a half, and he excels socially and intellectually. However, his attention span is still quite short, and he’s very much a four-year-old. The kindergarten curriculum feels more like what I remember from first grade. I anticipated more playtime and recess, not homework and concerns about him appearing tired and unfocused.
He now comes home with completed worksheets, which starkly contrasts with the creative projects he brought home just a few months ago. With studies suggesting that starting school later could be beneficial, perhaps it’s time to rethink the kindergarten curriculum to prioritize play over academic performance for our young children. Meanwhile, I find myself in meetings with school administrators who are convinced he is ready for kindergarten, assuming he just needs more interventions to succeed.
To me, he’s still a little boy. I wish for him to develop basic skills like holding a pencil, coloring, and nurturing the love for learning that led him to teach himself to read before turning four. If interventions are necessary, they should come when the lack of focus isn’t simply due to missing an afternoon nap.
For more insights on parenting and educational topics, consider checking out this article. It’s crucial to understand that educational approaches and environments significantly affect young learners. If you’re seeking resources for pregnancy and home insemination, March of Dimes has excellent guidance. And if you’re interested in at-home insemination kits, Cryobaby offers reputable options.
In summary, the pressure on kindergarten to mirror the first-grade experience may not be beneficial for our youngest learners. As parents, we must advocate for educational practices that nurture creativity and play rather than push early academic achievement.
Leave a Reply