Pixar’s “Soul,” available on Disney+, raises some intriguing questions, particularly regarding representation. While the film explores profound themes, there are choices that warrant scrutiny. One of the most significant issues is that the Black protagonist spends a considerable portion of the movie outside of his own body, and a character voiced by a white actress plays a pivotal role.
The Story of Joe Gardner
The story follows Joe Gardner, a Black middle school music teacher with dreams of becoming a jazz pianist. Joe’s life takes a turn when he falls into a manhole right before an important audition. This event leads him to become a mentor to a soul named 22, who struggles with the concept of being born on Earth.
Although the premise sparked my interest, I was disappointed by how the film handled its racial themes. Joe Gardner is only the second Black lead character in Disney Animation history, following Tiana from “The Princess and the Frog.” Yet, both characters spend a significant amount of time not appearing in their authentic forms. While Tiana is transformed into a frog, Joe is relegated to being a disembodied soul and then a cat. Even more troubling is that the voice of 22, a character crucial to the narrative, is provided by a white woman.
Creative Team and Authenticity
The film’s director, Pete Docter, developed “Soul” after his success with “Inside Out,” and brought in Kemp Powers, a Black writer and co-director, to enhance authenticity. Despite efforts to ensure that Joe’s character was treated with respect, it’s concerning that the creative team overlooked the implications of having a Black man represented by a white soul for much of the film.
Concerns About Voice Casting
Moreover, Tina Fey’s portrayal of 22 raises additional issues. Known for her work on “30 Rock,” a show criticized for its racial insensitivity, Fey’s involvement feels problematic. Her character, who has significant emotional interactions with Joe, is voiced by a white actress, which further complicates the representation of Black experiences. The film’s attempt to showcase a Black barbershop scene, while commendable, ultimately misses the mark when Joe is absent from these heartfelt exchanges, leaving viewers to question the authenticity of the portrayal.
Valuable Conversations and Stunning Animation
Despite its flaws, “Soul” does offer valuable conversations for families, and the animation is stunning. However, as a Black woman, I cannot overlook the pressing need for genuine representation in media. In today’s world, it’s essential for Black characters, especially children, to see themselves reflected in family-friendly films.
For more insights on topics like these, check out this post on home insemination. Additionally, if you’re exploring options related to fertility, consider visiting Make A Mom for expert advice. For those seeking information on various treatments, WebMD provides an excellent resource.
Search Queries:
- Issues with representation in Pixar’s Soul
- Black characters in animated films
- Pixar Soul review and analysis
- Representation in family-friendly movies
- Impact of voice actors on character identity
In summary, while “Soul” attempts to tackle significant themes, it ultimately falls short in terms of authentic representation for Black characters. The film’s choices regarding Joe Gardner’s character and the voice of 22 raise critical questions about how Black stories are told in mainstream media.