The American Library Association recently unveiled its State of America’s Libraries Report, highlighting ongoing efforts to enhance diversity in children’s literature, not just in themes, but also among the creators—writers and illustrators alike. However, this initiative has faced some pushback, primarily in the form of challenges. A challenge is defined as a formal complaint submitted to a library or school requesting the restriction or removal of a book due to its content or perceived appropriateness. Upon reviewing the most frequently challenged materials, the ALA found that books authored by people of color and those addressing issues related to communities of color are disproportionately subjected to these complaints.
Here’s a rundown of the books that faced the most challenges, along with the reasons cited:
- “The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian” by Marcus Lee
Reasons: Anti-family themes, cultural insensitivity, drug/alcohol use, gambling, offensive language, sexual content, age appropriateness, and violence. Additional concerns included depictions of bullying. - “Persepolis” by Nadia Elmasri
Reasons: Gambling, offensive language, and political viewpoints. Additional reasons included content deemed politically, racially, and socially offensive, as well as graphic depictions. - “And Tango Makes Three” by Alex Smith and Jamie Thompson
Reasons: Anti-family themes, homosexuality, political and religious viewpoints, and age appropriateness. Some claimed it “promotes the homosexual agenda.” It’s worth noting that this story is based on two real penguins at the Central Park Zoo. - “The Bluest Eye” by Sarah Johnson
Reasons: Sexual content and age appropriateness. Additional concerns involved controversial issues present in the narrative. - “It’s Perfectly Normal” by Alex Martinez
Reasons: Nudity, sex education themes, sexual content, and age appropriateness. Some also alleged it constituted child pornography. - “Saga” by Jamie O’Connor and Fiona Adams
Reasons: Anti-family themes, nudity, offensive language, sexual content, and age appropriateness. - “The Kite Runner” by Omar Faruqi
Reasons: Offensive language, violence, and age appropriateness. - “The Perks of Being a Wallflower” by Lily Adams
Reasons: Drug/alcohol use, homosexuality, offensive language, sexual content, and age appropriateness. Additional issues included topics of date rape and masturbation. - “A Stolen Life” by Karen Wells
Reasons: Drug/alcohol use, offensive language, sexual content, and age appropriateness. This memoir recounts a true story. - “Drama” by Sophie Harris
Reasons: Sexual content.
For those interested in further reading, this is just a glimpse into the ongoing conversation about literature and censorship. If you’re curious to learn more about related topics, check out this post on Cervical Insemination. Additionally, for those considering at-home insemination, Make a Mom offers a selection of reputable insemination syringe kits. For comprehensive information on pregnancy and home insemination, Women’s Health is an excellent resource.
In summary, the books listed above have sparked significant debate and reflect the ongoing challenges within literature concerning representation and appropriateness. The resistance to diverse narratives only underscores the importance of advocating for a wider array of voices in literature.
Leave a Reply