The recent announcement from the Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus about its impending closure in May marks the end of a 146-year era. Reactions have varied; some people expressed shock, others reminisced fondly, while many celebrated the decision. Personally, I find myself asking, why did it take so long?
The circus’s closure is a complex issue with significant ramifications. Job losses loom for those who have dedicated their lives to this unique culture, and animals will face uncertain futures. A long-standing American tradition is fading away. However, when we consider the underlying cruelty often associated with this “tradition,” it becomes clear that it is time for a change.
Many of us cherish childhood memories of the circus—the excitement of the train rolling in, the vibrant performers, and the awe-inspiring animals. In those moments, we were blissfully unaware of the troubling realities hidden behind the scenes. As we matured, we began to notice the unsettling truths but often chose to ignore them. Perhaps it was the sight of a bullhook or the first glimpse of an animal being mistreated that stirred our conscience. Or maybe it was the sight of a majestic elephant performing unnatural tricks, leaving us with a nagging intuition that something was amiss.
For some, the revelation came later in life through literature like Water for Elephants or children’s books such as The One and Only Ivan. Documentaries and investigative reports unveiled the grim realities, such as the tragic story of Kenny, a young elephant who died while on tour with Ringling Bros. in 1998. Investigations have revealed widespread abuses, including disease among animals, separation of mothers and their babies, and prolonged confinement in chains.
As an animal lover myself, I’ve always been uneasy about the circus. I consider my pets family and go to great lengths to avoid causing harm to any creature. My few visits to the circus were filled with conflicting emotions: the joy of my son’s excitement clashed with my discomfort over the treatment of the animals. He adored riding the elephants and watching tigers perform, while I struggled to suppress the unsettling thoughts that surfaced each time.
Criticism of the circus regarding animal treatment has been ongoing, and as awareness grows, more people are unwilling to overlook the suffering animals endure for our entertainment. Janice Hill, a spokesperson for Animal Rights Advocates, stated, “The public is more informed now. They recognize the suffering and cruelty inflicted upon animals for mere moments of amusement.”
For some, the circus’s closing may evoke mixed feelings, but for me, it leans more toward relief than regret. I don’t want to witness any animal suffering for any amount of time, whether it’s 15 minutes or 15 seconds. While there are jobs at stake due to the circus’s end, it doesn’t have to be a matter of sacrificing one for the other. We can advocate for animal welfare while finding new employment opportunities for those impacted. Families can enjoy quality time with animals—both domestic and wild—without compromising their wellbeing. Visiting animal sanctuaries, checking out Cirque du Soleil, or even volunteering at a local animal shelter can provide fulfilling alternatives. For those looking for at-home insemination options, reputable retailers like CryoBaby offer a variety of kits that can be helpful. Additionally, resources like Medical News Today provide valuable information about fertility and pregnancy.
In essence, while some may reminisce about what was once dubbed the “greatest show on earth,” I feel a sense of joy at the curtain finally falling on this chapter. And let’s not even start on the clowns.
Summary
The closure of the Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus is a significant moment, reflecting a shift in societal values regarding animal welfare. While it brings job losses and a sense of nostalgia for some, many celebrate the end of an era marked by questionable practices and cruelty. As we move forward, we can find new ways to enjoy animals and support their well-being without compromising their quality of life.